Over 27 years after William P. Bengen published what he referred to as the SAFEMAX rate in the October 1994 issue of the Journal of Financial Planning, the four percent rule still stands as one of the most widely used rules of thumb in retirement planning. Let’s take a look to see how it has developed over time, and how applicable it still is in today’s current economic climate.
When Bengen first published his rule, he called it the SAFEMAX rate because it was meant to represent the maximum “safe” withdrawal rate through the historically worst-cases of economic scenarios. He started with the main base assumptions that the withdrawal rate would have to be persistent over three decades, which would last most aged 65 and over retirees a lifetime. He then wanted the withdrawal rate to be indexed for inflation and preserve purchasing power. He also further assumed that the distributions would be taken from a pre-tax retirement portfolio, such as an IRA or 401(k), eliminating some of the negative tax consequences along the way.
Using over 50 years of historical data on stocks and bonds, he came up with an initial withdrawal rate of 4.2% for the initial year, and suggested this number be adjusted every subsequent year for inflation. This would be the annual rate that a 65-year-old retiree would be able to withdraw and have a very high probability of never outliving their money. In 2006, Bengen refined this number to 4.5% if the account is tax-free and 4.1% if it is taxable.
When creating the rule, Bengen assumed a 50/50 asset allocation throughout the life of the plan. He later advocated for as much as 75% in stocks, before settling on a slightly more conservative number at 55%. His rationale being that you need to have a larger portion of your account allocated towards stocks to combat inflation and maintain purchasing power over time. On the bond side, Bengen used intermediate-term government bonds to further hedge against inflation and because he thought they provided the proper amount of premium for their risk level.
This withdrawal rate doesn’t come without some caveats. When using the four percent rule throughout retirement, the retiree must strictly adhere to the constant distribution rate. Any deviation greater than this rate, negative performance in the early years, or the necessity for larger distributions at the start of the distribution period can have severe consequences to the overall likelihood of the plan’s success.
The rule also does not make any guarantees for longevity risk beyond 30 years of distributions. This would normally be an issue for a 65-year-old retiree who lives past 95, however because no historical plan using the four percent withdrawal rate failed, every plan had maintained at least some portion of their principal at the end of 30 years. Bengen actually found that at a 4.5% withdrawal rate, 96% of the plans maintained their initial balance at the end of the 30-year distribution period. On top of that, over two-thirds of the time the ending principal was more than double the initial starting balance.
When Bengen created the rule he looked at three of the worst historical economic periods of his time, the “Little Dipper” 1929-1931, the “Big Dipper” 1937-1941, and the “Big Bang” 1973-1974. Since his study, there have been a couple other significant economic downturns, the tech collapse of 2000 and the great recession of 2008. While these financial crises may have appeared detrimental at the time, the magnitude and quickness of their recovery periods has them still on track or doing better than any of the historical scenarios that Bengen looked at.
And so, we arrive back to Bengen’s original conclusion and one that has so far stood the test of time. The four percent withdrawal rate can be used as a starting point and rule of thumb to find a distribution percentage that can be safely used as a guideline for retirees to live off their retirement nest egg without ever having to worry about running out of money. Like any rule, the caveats and assumptions must be followed while also continuously rebalancing. With decades of data to back it up, one can rest pretty solidly with the four percent rule.
As always it is best to consult with a professional financial planner to ensure you are on a successful path towards retirement.
Click here to read more of my RetireMint articles. Follow me on Twitter or Linkedin.
- May 19, 2022
- May 12, 2022
- April 21, 2022
- April 6, 2022
- March 31, 2022
- March 17, 2022
- February 25, 2022
- February 22, 2022
- February 9, 2022
- January 27, 2022
- January 20, 2022
- January 11, 2022
- December 29, 2021
- December 17, 2021
- December 16, 2021
- December 14, 2021
- December 9, 2021-2
- December 9, 2021
- November 30, 2021
- November 23, 2021-2
- November 23, 2021
- November 19, 2021
- November 18, 2021
- October 25, 2021
- October 21, 2021
- October 20, 2021
- October 1, 2021
- September 16, 2021
- September 15-2, 2021
- September 15, 2021-2
- August 24, 2021
- August 18, 2021
- August 12, 2021-2
- August 12, 2021-1
- August 11, 2021
- July 22, 2021
- June 24, 2021
- June 22, 2021
- June 16, 2021
- May 25, 2021-2
- May 25, 2021
- May 19, 2021
- April 27, 2021
- April 21, 2021
- March 25, 2021-2
- March 25, 2021
- March 17, 2021
- March 5, 2021
- February 17, 2021
- February 10, 2021-2
- February 10, 2021
- January 27, 2021
- January 25, 2021
- January 15, 2021
- December 17, 2020
- December 10, 2020
- December 8, 2020
- November 17-2, 2020
- November 17, 2020
- November 3, 2020
- October 30, 2020
- October 28, 2020
- September 23, 2020
- September 15, 2020
- September 1, 2020
- August 27, 2020
- August 25, 2020
- August 11, 2020
- August 11, 2020
- August 5, 2020
- July 1, 2020
- June 19, 2020
- June 9, 2020
- June 4, 2020
- June 2, 2020-2
- June 2, 2020
- May 21, 2020
- May 18, 2020
- April 15, 2020
- April 8, 2020
- April 8, 2020
- April 7, 2020
- April 1, 2020
- February 27, 2020
- February 25, 2020
- February 18, 2020
- February 12, 2020
- February 11, 2020
- February 11, 2020
- February 10, 2020
- January 16, 2020
- January 14, 2020
- January 2, 2020-8
- January 2, 2020-7
- January 2, 2020-6
- January 2, 2020-5
- January 2, 2020-4
- January 2, 2020-3
- January 2, 2020-2
- January 2, 2020-1
- December 13, 2019
- December 11, 2019
- December 9, 2019
- November 27, 2019
- November 13, 2019
- October 29, 2019
- October 23, 2019
- October 19, 2019
- October 18, 2019
- October 10, 2019
- October 9, 2019
- October 4, 2019
- September 19, 2019
- September 19, 2019
- August 15, 2019
- August 15, 2019
- August 15, 2019
- August 15, 2019
- August 15, 2019
- July 25, 2019
- July 24, 2019
- June 27, 2019
- June 27, 2019
- June 6, 2019
- June 6, 2019
- May 22, 2019
- May 20, 2019
- May 20, 2019
- April 25, 2019
- April 25, 2019
- April 4, 2019
- April 4, 2019
- March 28, 2019
- March 28, 2019
- March 28, 2019
- March 27, 2019
- March 25, 2019
- March 18, 2019
- March 13, 2019
- March 11, 2019
- February 28, 2019
- February 11, 2019
- February 4, 2019
- February 4, 2019
- February 4, 2019
- February 1, 2019
- January 29, 2019
- January 21, 2019
- January 18, 2019
- January 14, 2019
- January 14, 2019
- December 28, 2018
- December 28, 2018
- December 26, 2018
- December 24, 2018
- December 14, 2018
- December 10, 2018
- November 12, 2018
- October 25, 2018
- October 24, 2018
- October 24, 2018
- October 23, 2018
- October 23, 2018
- October 12, 2018
- Septmember 28, 2018
- Septmember 28, 2018
- Septmember 25, 2018
- Septmember 24, 2018
- August 28, 2018
- August 10, 2018
- August 9, 2018
- August 8, 2018
- August 8, 2018
- August 8, 2018
- August 7, 2018
- August 2, 2018
- July 31, 2018
- July 26, 2018
- July 25, 2018
- July 3, 2018
- May 3, 2018
- May 2, 2018
- April 26, 2018
- April 25, 2018
- April 16, 2018
- April 3, 2018
- March 23, 2018
- March 22, 2018
- March 21, 2018
- March 7, 2018
- February 20, 2018
- February 6, 2018
- February 6, 2018
- January 22, 2018
- January 16, 2018
- January 9, 2018
- January 5, 2018
- January 5, 2018
- December 29, 2017
- December 28, 2017
- December 21, 2017
- December 4, 2017
- November 26, 2017
- November 16, 2017
- November 14, 2017
- November 6, 2017
- October 27, 2017
- October 25, 2017
- October 24, 2017
- October 16, 2017
- September 7, 2017
- September 5, 2017
- August 16, 2017
- August 11, 2017
- August 8, 2017
- July 21, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- July 3, 2017
- June 23, 2017
- June 21, 2017
- June 16, 2017
- May 5, 2017
- May 2, 2017
- March 30, 2017
- March 30, 2017
- March 30, 2017
- March 2, 2017
- February 6, 2017
- January 10, 2017
- December 28, 2016
- December 2, 2016
- December 1, 2016
- November 23, 2016
- October 29, 2016
- October 17, 2016
- October 16, 2016
- September 20, 2016
- September 13, 2016
- August 8, 2016
- July 1, 2016
- May 8, 2016
- March 31, 2016
- March 28, 2016
- March 28, 2016
- March 14, 2016
- February 26, 2016
- February 22, 2016
- February 17, 2016
- January 12, 2016
- January 11, 2016
- November 5, 2015
- November 5, 2015
- November 5, 2015
- September 30, 2015
- September 29, 2015
- September 22, 2015
- September 22, 2015
- September 1, 2015
- July 29, 2015
- July 29, 2015
- July 19, 2015
- May 19, 2015
- April 27, 2015
- March 26, 2015
- March 23, 2015
- February 27, 2015
- December 12, 2014
- December 11, 2014
- October 15, 2014
- October 1, 2014
- June 4, 2014
- May 29, 2014
- February 21, 2014
- February 10, 2014
- December 10, 2013
- March 23, 2018 - Radio
- March 23, 2018 - TV
Important Consumer Disclosure
Mainstay Capital Management, LLC is an investment advisor registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Due to various state regulations and filing requirements, Mainstay and its representatives may only provide investment advisory services in those states in which it is first appropriately registered or otherwise exempt or excluded from registration requirements. The purpose of this website is to provide the public with general information about the services offered by our investment management firm. Mainstay does not render personalized investment advice or services or effect, or attempt to effect any securities transactions, on this website. Our firm continuously monitors its filing requirements in all states, and will provide individualized advisory services only in accordance with various state regulations. Mainstay does not make any representations or warranties as to the accuracy, completeness, or relevance of any information prepared by any unaffiliated third party provider, whether linked to Mainstay's website or incorporated herein. All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly.